At Carey Insurance, our vision is to THRIVE by building local relationships, helping Ocala grow without compromising its roots, by being genuine and advising and helping others. We believe in doing right by people, being ourselves, and embracing the essence of living. Through teamwork, we foster an environment that is honest, respectful, and innovative, encouraging vibrant growth in our community. Our commitment to excellence drives us to continually deliver exceptional experiences and make a positive impact on the lives of those we serve. Our values are at the core of everything we do:

TEAMWORK: We embrace teamwork to deliver exceptional service and support to our clients. We collaborate seamlessly, combining our diverse skills and knowledge to provide comprehensive insurance solutions that meet the unique needs of the Ocala community.

HONESTY: Honesty is the cornerstone of our agency’s values. We operate with utmost transparency, integrity, and ethical standards. Our commitment to honesty ensures that our clients can trust us to provide reliable insurance advice, accurate information, and fair treatment in every interaction.

RESPECTFUL: Carey Insurance fosters a culture of respect, treating each client, colleague, and community member with dignity and consideration. We listen attentively, value diverse perspectives, and respond with empathy. We understand that respect forms the foundation of long-lasting relationships built on trust and mutual understanding.

INNOVATIVE: As an independent insurance agency, we strive to be at the forefront of innovation in our industry. We continuously explore new technologies, embrace emerging trends, and seek innovative solutions to better serve our clients. By staying ahead of the curve, we offer cutting-edge insurance options that provide enhanced protection and convenience.

VIBRANT: Our agency thrives on vitality and energy, infusing vibrancy into everything we do. We approach our work with enthusiasm and passion, creating a dynamic atmosphere that is contagious. We believe that a vibrant attitude not only enhances our own effectiveness but also inspires our clients and community to actively engage with us.

EXCELLENCE: Excellence is our standard at every level of our agency. We are committed to delivering outstanding service, superior products, and exceptional customer experiences. We continuously strive for excellence through ongoing professional development, rigorous quality control measures, and a dedication to exceeding our clients’ expectations. Our pursuit of excellence sets us apart in the Ocala community. By adhering to these values and embracing our vision, we are dedicated to making a positive difference in the lives of individuals and the community we serve.



What Our Clients Say



Cindy is great. She went out of her way to make sure my family and I have the best home owner insurance at the best premium. It is great to know that my local agent puts me and my insurance need’s as a priority. Thank you Carey Insurance for the great personal service. It is nice to have a friend in the insurance business.

Cary E.


Cyndi did a great job! Excellent service and very responsive. I would highly recommend them for all your insurance needs.

Paul C.


Great service for 7 years and staff has always been able to answer any questions that I had. Trust them with my insurance needs.

Kevin D.


Carey Insurance is the best! I use them for my home & auto insurance. They have given me competitive rates for years and are easy to work with. I would highly recommend Mike & his team to anyone.

Abigail S.


We’ve had all our insurance policies written by the great staff at Carey Insurance. Lisa and Cyndi recently helped me with some documents that were needed , they were super friendly and accommodating through the process and even gave some great advice ! I recommend calling these ladies you wont be disappointed

Nina S.