Carey Insurance was first created and established by Bob Carey, Mike Carey’s grandfather in 1969. Although Bob went on to pursue other ventures, and ultimately sold it in 1989, as Mike puts it, “I wasn’t quite old enough to get into the insurance business at the age of 5.” So, after finishing college at Florida State, he moved back to Ocala, with his then-fiance-turned-wife, Jenn in 2008. He entered the insurance business with a small independent agency and found his calling to serve the people of Ocala and the surrounding areas. Mike opened the Carey Insurance you know today, in 2010, and has never looked back. He believes in a local agency feel, where staff can truly understand their customer’s needs. Carey Insurance strives to offer all insurance services under one roof: homes, renters, automobiles, ATVs, boats, RVs, businesses, and life.


We’ve built our business around listening to our customers’ needs. When you have the right coverage that you need, you’ll get peace of mind. That’s Carey Insurance. – Mike Carey


Mike Carey started Carey Insurance in 2005. He believed that a local agent with a caring staff could create value in the community of Ocala, FL for his customers and for his family. Mike’s vision to offer all services under one roof has lead Carey Insurance to offering insurance for: home, renter’s, automobiles, ATV, boats, RVs, businesses, and life insurance.


What Our Clients Say



Cindy is great. She went out of her way to make sure my family and I have the best home owner insurance at the best premium. It is great to know that my local agent puts me and my insurance need’s as a priority. Thank you Carey Insurance for the great personal service. It is nice to have a friend in the insurance business.

Cary E.


Cyndi did a great job! Excellent service and very responsive. I would highly recommend them for all your insurance needs.

Paul C.


Great service for 7 years and staff has always been able to answer any questions that I had. Trust them with my insurance needs.

Kevin D.


Carey Insurance is the best! I use them for my home & auto insurance. They have given me competitive rates for years and are easy to work with. I would highly recommend Mike & his team to anyone.

Abigail S.


We’ve had all our insurance policies written by the great staff at Carey Insurance. Lisa and Cyndi recently helped me with some documents that were needed , they were super friendly and accommodating through the process and even gave some great advice ! I recommend calling these ladies you wont be disappointed

Nina S.